I’ve been absent from SoG for a while since discovering Post Captain. No game ive ever played has been a better simulation while somehow also not being overwhelming at all.

With PC as my more serious game, SoG has been more of a quick beer and pretzels game with the simple rules.

Would love to see how these other two systems compare though. Black Seas is the same period as Sails of Glory, Oak & Iron is 17th century buccaneers and fleets.

There are some old threads when these systems first came out, but nothing new. How do they compare in fun, realism, and playtime to SoG?.