What we need is some mathematical Guru to give us a statistical breakdown of the variables for each ships hitting power at long range/short range, firstly without Carronades and then using them over the course of a whole battle. This must also include the probability of mixed munitions bring employed,and the style of fighting of the player/ captain. We may then get close to finding out if they are an asset or a hindrance to a victory for any particular combination of ships.


Failing that just keep up the good work Fred and DB to get us a reasonable rule fit to reality, and I will be happy with whatever you decide.
Rob.