Search:

David,

I hope the stats committee, officially releases a corrected/alternate Amazon.

Everyone:

TOS and Enterprise (Enterprise would have been slightly better had they not allowed in the...

Sven,

Perhaps not looking at this correctly. But seems to me in this game they widely lumped ships together. Which for simplicity sake makes really good sense. Okay having said that, unrated...

Quite right!:thumbsup:

Cerberus was a mod-Pallas class but was armed similar to Amphion, but was about 100tons lighter. Active came out close enough to a Hebe, I left it alone.

Eric,

You are right, I had forgotten that. When I researched the ships, Amphion was not the Amazon class ship by the same name. As a matter of fact, Amphion is also the class of this ship that...

Agreed, and if you look at the scenario section of WSIM, HMS Amphion for Battle of Lissa is actually rated as hull 7. There was another scenario example that was 7 also. I believe the standard...

I'm almost tempted to make my Amazon's burden 3.

My hope is that this was an error or oversight, and not a play balancing attempt. This type of play balancing is ineffective, in light of the intent to add more variety of units at a later date. ...

All of the reasons above, is why I think the burden assigned to the Amazon's were a publishing/design error. The Amazon's were heavier, they had heavier guns, they were shorter, but made up with...

Hey, who peed on my poop sandwich?

Seriously though, back on topic. We will have to move the stats discussion to here because we can't discuss stats in the stats committee thread.

Eric...

A pain in the stern could give you a bowe (bend) in your bow (or should we say bowel). :happy:

Fly-X-Wire (Dave) on this forum schedules our game days. Yes we definitely need to get some SoG action going this year! We were playing fairly steady down here, but haven't played recently...

Paul,

I took no offense. Just wanted to be clear in regards to motives. I enjoy the conversation!:thumbsup:

Bob

Eric & Paul,

Not trying to tear the game down. It's a fun quick age of sail game that I'll be playing many years from now. However, a couple of issues spring to mind where understanding the...

Yes the number of damage boxes (not the sub burden damage) seem to be standard by rating. I suspect Constitution will show damage more in line with a 4th rate.

I have tried multiple formula, and nothing works. I've used Wikipedia and this site for a lot of research:

http://threedecks.org/index.php?display_type=home

Concorde BM 500-550tn Length of...

I started wargaming in the 70's. The old Avalon Hill, SPI and GDW games almost all included designer's notes, so that you could visualize how the writer developed the concept. Current games, never...