Search:

Yes it would help, but that first devastating broadside still will make any Nelson heroics with 74s near impossible.

I only mentioned gunner skill as it had been mentioned and it wouldn't work as...

The Spanish first rates stats are over gunned compared to British and French first rates regardless if you compare broadside weight or number of guns, even if compensating for most effective caliber....

The Spanish ships have very high fire power ratings without any real explanation. I wouldn't use a battle against them as a measure.

It's a little better. From memory I think it was a little complicated to calculate ob the fly though.

My main complain with the carronade rule is the extremes that make for strange effect. An all...

It's overpowered in every version of the rules.

I found that effect and that's one of the reasons I don't use it. It's just too good. I think it's a little bit like cheating.