Wind Table Variations

Attachment 48088

Attachment 48089

Attachment 48090

THESE TABLES HAVE ERRORS. THE CORRECTED ONES ARE AT POST #9.

Here are some wind tables I developed. I use a plus and minus chit from the original game wind chits as well as one clockwise and one counter-clockwise chit. I roll at the start of each turn before cards are chosen.

I felt there needed to be three different "styles" of wind, for the open ocean, near coastal, and bays or headlands where the wind is always shifting.

My idea is to make the wind able to wander, but always trend toward the speed and direction that it was at the start of the game.

For wind speed, if an increase or decrease is rolled, the appropriate marker is placed on the Wind Gauge. On subsequent turns, if the same effect is rolled, the speed changes and the marker is removed. If the opposite is rolled, nothing happens and the marker is removed from the Wind Gauge. If No Effect is rolled and a chit is out, the chit stays. If the wind speed increases from the speed at the start of the engagement, a modifier of -1 is added to the die roll each turn. If the wind speed decreases from the speed at the start of the engagement, a modifier of +1 is added to the die roll each turn.

For wind direction, if a wind shift is rolled, the appropriate marker is placed on the Wind Gauge. On subsequent turns, if the same effect is rolled, the direction changes and the marker is removed. If the opposite is rolled, nothing happens and the marker is removed from the Wind Gauge. If No Effect is rolled and a chit is out, the chit stays. If the wind direction shifts counter-clockwise from the direction at the start of the engagement, a modifier of +1 is added to the die roll each turn. If the wind direction shifts clockwise from the direction at the start of the engagement, a modifier of -1 is added to the die roll each turn.

I allowed for a greater range for the wind, but the tables work with just the regular three wind settings in the middle. I print the sheets out, cover the print with some self-laminate, and spray some adhesive on the back to attach them to a bit of cardboard or craft foam.

That is very creative, Dobbs. :thumbsup: I do not think that I have played any games using variable wind speed.

A very interesting set of tables Dobbs.
As an aficionado of changes in the wind myself, I will be taking those onboard in my next forray.
Rob.

Interesting, and I like that the original direction/strength get a weight in the following changes.

Yes it really brings what was just a bit more chit shuffling to life, and as the wind status was so important in so many battles it is an influential amendment to make in the game. I use wind direction in the general way but have only added the strength in the last year, so this will refine that aspect of my game even more so.
Rob.

I've played so few games I can't comment on this but my last game was the Feb 2015 Solo Campaign scenario, one of Neil's I believe and I had a 74gun v a 100gun ship, because I had the weather gauge as well as a couple of other things in my favour I pasted the bigger ship. So I expect these rules will add a whole new level to the games.

Yes, I remembering playing that. First try I had the first rate just turn straight onto land and get stuck. I had to move it out of the mouth of the river and manually override doing anything that would get it stuck until it was out of the immediate danger from the lee shore. And looking at the pictures I'm very sad I hadn't built the terrain for the coastline yet. It does make a huge difference to me.

Anyhow, did you put up an AAR?

Gents, I just realized that there are a number of proofreading errors on my tables, so I will correct and repost them soon.

Here are the corrected tables:

Attachment 48108

Attachment 48109

Attachment 48110

Thanks Dobbs.
I will download as soon as my upgrades are finally reinstalled.
Meanwhile here is a bit of Rep for all the work.
Rob.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by TexaS

Yes, I remembering playing that. First try I had the first rate just turn straight onto land and get stuck. I had to move it out of the mouth of the river and manually override doing anything that would get it stuck until it was out of the immediate danger from the lee shore. And looking at the pictures I'm very sad I hadn't built the terrain for the coastline yet. It does make a huge difference to me.

Anyhow, did you put up an AAR?

---

Jonas I am away for 2 months but I've brought my notes and pictures and so hope to post this game before I get back home. I think I had a very similar experience to you. I'm just pleased I won the previous game and had the wind in my favour because it was a nightmare trying to beat out of the very narrow gap between the mainland and the island for my enemy and it would have been a much more difficult game if the wind had been against me.

Saved them now Dobbs. I am learning my way around my new setup.
Seems to be working OK, but has not solved my attatchment problem.
Rob.