Jim, I think this would make for a good house rule test for the second set of solo rules. We could do this now for DB, providing him feedback, and based on our experience, flesh out an entire carronade set of rules. I'll have to check, but I think Bobby and others have made some carronade suggestions previously. I think there is enough knowledge and experience among folks here that we could develop something quite useful - not just general carronade rules, but also specific swaps like DB is suggesting. Folks could then have rules and a ship roster.