Printable View
I thought the Anchorage might appreciate this discussion over on FB. It discusses traversing of guns to achieve oblique fire and the gunnery innovations of HMS Shannon, as well as some anecdotes from the Master and Commander film.
https://www.facebook.com/groups/patr...0270405424753/
That was a lot of fun. I have just been reading "The Fortunes of War" by Patrick O'Brian covering the Shannon/Chesapeake action.
In scrolling down the FB page I saw the interesting cannon. Here's one I came across the other day.
Attachment 59982
Attachment 59983
Attachment 59984
It's like a carronade, but breachloading. It looks like someone at the other end of the 19th century thought that there might be a use for the return of them, but riled too! The black sleeves conceal springs to absorb the recoil.
Interesting little chaps Dobbs. I would not park my car in that parking lot opposite!
Rob.
A very interesting bit of research Howard. I took the liberty of copying a couple of the diagrams for future use.Quote:
Originally Posted by SkeenaH
Rob.
Hmm... maybe HMS Shannon, for each chit thrown, draws two and selects which one gets applied? (Chit by chit, this means on a 3 broadside draw two and apply one, draw another pair and apply one, repeat a third time, not draw six all at once pick three.)
Or would just throw back and redraw zeroes be better?
I think since Broke's training emphasised accuracy which increased the chances of hits, perhaps return zeroes and redraw, although this is a big advantage. It's essentially the 'Good Aim' card but as a permanent effect. Perhaps allowing the 'Good Aim' card to be used 4 or 5 times per engagement may be fairer, or perhaps for the first 4 or 5 broadsides (after which accuracy would decline given fatigue, heated gun barrels etc).
I think selecting between chits already drawn allows for upgrading damage, and while accuracy was increased, damage was probably still dependent on lady fortune to an extent...
I have ordered Broke of the Shannon book and will probably order the reprint of the Evolution of Naval Armament which discusses gunnery: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/56777
I love rabbit holes!
An interesting aside for those that don't know already but Broke's name is pronounced "Brook" :)
That is an interesting aside. I didn't know that, and it adds a conversational level that reading doesn't always do.Quote:
Originally Posted by David Manley
The other question is, should this be treated as Unique to Broke, or a Crew/Equipment ability? Did anybody else follow his example, or did later captains of Shannon continue the practice?
Alternately, maybe allow use of full Main broadside value in either Fore or Aft fire arcs once per game? Did Broke set up only for range or did he train 'em dialing in for azimuth off center-of-LOF too?
As we have no conclusive evidence as to any other captain following Brokes idea, and until someone uncovers any, I suggest that we treat Broke as a special case. The simple answer is to follow Howard's thinking with the good aim card.
Rob.